Awards
- Top Resort - Conde Nast Traveler 2011 and 2010 Readers' Choice Awards
- Certificate of Excellence - TripAdvisor 2011
- Top 100 Resort Spas in the U.S. - Conde Nast Traveler 2011 Readers' Spa Poll
- Top 125 Golf Resorts - Conde Nast Traveler 2011 Readers' Golf Poll
- Top 500 World's Best Hotels - Travel + Leisure (2008, 2009, 2010)
- 2010 Gold Award Premier Resort - GOLF Magazine
- Best Lodging in the Midwest - GOLF Magazine
- Best Golf in the Midwest - GOLF Magazine
- Favorite Place on Google.com
- Top 75 Golf Resorts in North America (#41) - Golf Digest
- Best Michigan Hotel (#3) - The Oakland Press
- Best Wedding Receptions (#3) - The Graphic Best of the Northwest
- Best Spa (#1) - The Graphic Best of the Northwest
- Best Hotel/Motel (#3) - The Graphic Best of the Northwest
- Best Golf Course, Bay Harbor Golf Club (#3) - The Graphic Best of the Northwest
- Best Hotel with Meeting Space (200 guest rooms or less) - Michigan Meetings + Events Annual Readers' Poll
- Award of Excellence - Wine Spectator
- Best Golf Resort (runner-up)- Michigan Meetings + Events Annual Readers' Poll
- Silver Medal Award - GOLF Magazine
- Most Underrated Resort in the Midwest - Travel + Leisure GOLF
- Great Golf Resorts of the World - PGA magazine
- 2008 Michigan Course of the Year - National Golf Course Owners Association
- Top 100 Golf Resorts (#8) - Conde Nast Traveler annual reader survey
- "10 Best Family-Boating Resorts" - Boating Life magazine
- Ranked #1 Hotel in Petoskey, Tripadvisor.com
- Best for Massage, Winter Sports and Meetings - Spa Finder Readers' Choice Awards
- "Customer Service Overall," "Savvy Service Award" and "General Manager of the Year" -Marriott International and Renaissance Hotels & Resorts
- Best Midwest Golf Resorts (#3) - Travel + Leisure GOLF
- Best Resorts for Buddy Trips (#3) - Travel + Leisure GOLF
- Best Resort Courses (#3) - Travel + Leisure GOLF
- Best Restaurants (#2) - Travel + Leisure GOLF
- America's Top 75 Golf Resorts (#20) - Golf Digest
- Pinnacle Award, Outstanding Meeting Facilities - Successful Meetings
- Most Spectacular Condo Hotel, Michigan Book of Bests